arXiv ID Shape

Agent readability score

Strengths

• Some tool names (e.g., 'arxiv-id-shape') clearly indicate their purpose
• Descriptions occasionally mention data handling (e.g., 'discarded' in 'validate-json')

Weaknesses

• Most tool names are generic (e.g., 'utc-time', 'timezone') with no contextual differentiation
• All tools share identical optional parameters without clear required fields
• 30+ tools have overlapping functions (e.g., 'browser-url-ok' vs 'playwright-url-ok')
• No error handling or constraint documentation in any tool descriptions
• Descriptions often fail to explain when tools should be used, only what they do

• utc-time — Generic name with no contextual differentiation
• timezone — Generic name with no contextual differentiation
• browser-url-ok — Functionally redundant with 'playwright-url-ok'
• web-fetch — Overlapping purpose with 'fetch-status'
• validate-json — No clear required parameters specified

Verdict

The toolset suffers from severe naming ambiguity, functional overlap, and parameter uniformity. With 30+ tools sharing identical optional parameters and no clear differentiation in descriptions, the agent would struggle to select appropriate tools. The lack of error handling documentation and contextual usage guidance further reduces usability.

9/13/2026, 12:12:52 AM

Event narrative

arXiv ID Shape server in legacy era shows 100% compliance with no smoke test results

Risk: low

• 2026-09-12T15:21:42.024Z — Server entered legacy era with 100% compliance score (smoke test results missing) · Stable operation confirmed but requires smoke test data validation

Advice

Investigate missing smoke test results for legacy era confirmation. Maintain monitoring for compliance score fluctuations. Ensure legacy era status is intentional.